Tonight’s Supper: Vegan Shepherd’s Pie
Tonight’s Sunday Supper Soundtrack: Spotify’s “Decades Dance Party” playlist (don’t judge me!)
As always, there are more pictures on instagram under the hashtag #sundaysupper
I was introduced to vegetarian shepherd’s pie by my partner, many years ago. He always makes his with store bought vegan ground beef substitute, but here on the island, that can be hard to find. Often I use lentils instead, and those work well, but this week they didn’t have any lentils at the store and I really wanted shepherd’s pie, so I had to get creative. Thinking over and discarding several thoughts (chickpeas? black beans?), I finally settled on mushrooms as having the proper amount of toothiness, plus the ability to absorb the flavors of the seasonings.
I started, as usual, by boiling the potatoes until they were soft, then mashing them with soymilk, earth balance vegan margarine, and salt. I always leave the skin on my mashed potatoes, but you could take it off if you wanted.

Then I chopped the mushrooms, leaving them fairly large to add some texture to the finished product. I sauteed them with salt, black pepper, thyme, parsley, and dill.

Once those were done, I was ready to layer the pie. First, 1/2 the mashed potatoes; then the mushrooms; then the creamed corn; and last the rest of the potatoes. Normally I would top it with some Daiya cheddar cheese, but I ate the last of what I had a few days ago, so no more cheese for me until my next mainland trip!
Pop it in the oven at 350 for 15 minutes or so, and you’re done!
Note on mushrooms: The mushrooms worked very well as a meat substitute, but the end result was a bit potato heavy, so you might want to adjust your amounts depending on how much potato you want. I will probably use more mushrooms next time I make this.
Ingredients: 4 large russet potatoes; 2 cups mushrooms, coarsely chopped (see note on mushrooms, above); 1 can creamed corn; salt, black pepper, thyme, parsley, and dill, to taste (for mushrooms); vegan cheese for topping (optional)
1. Boil potatoes until they are soft enough to mash. Should take about 10 minutes, once the water starts boiling.
2. Drain the potatoes. Mash with a little bit of soy milk, butter substitute, and salt to taste.
3. Saute the mushrooms with olive oil, salt, black pepper, thyme, parsley, and dill, until the mushrooms are tender and have started to exude moisture.
4. Layer the shepherd’s pie in a medium sized casserole dish: 1/2 the potatoes, then the mushrooms, then the creamed corn, then the rest of the potatoes. Top with vegan cheese, if desired.
5. Bake at 350 for about 15 minutes, or until vegan cheese is melted and pie is heated through.